From Left to Right: The Comedian, Nite Owl, Rorschach, Dr. Manhattan, The Silk Spectre, Ozymandias Credit: www.comicsymascomics.com |
Watchmen is hailed as one of the greatest graphic novels ever created. It won so much critical acclaim and when reading it, it seems it would easily translate to film. So when the movie was released back in 2009, why didn't it? The graphic novel itself is on DC's list of "essential" reads, along with V For Vendetta, The Killing Joke, and Batman: Year One. But the movie tanked at the box office? Lets explore why, and what could be done to give this story the cinematic adaptation that it deserves.
Watchmen is set in an alternate 1985 where the world is on edge and paranoid for the start of World War III. The worlds group of major superheroes and masked vigilantes have been outlawed and must therefor work for the government which causes a slew of chaos amongst the world when the only two heroes on board with the government are either killed or exiled. One by one we see these masked heroes get picked off by an unknown villain and it's up to the vigilante Rorschach and the old gang of Watchmen to find out who, and before World War III starts.
Credit: www.superhero-wallpapers.com |
It's a simple enough tale, but the graphic novel was hailed for it's psychological writing, it's gripping narrative and parallel structure that made it a truly amazing book that should have translated well into a movie. So why did the movie fail to bring such acclaim at the box office? For starters, it was not exactly comic accurate. The director, Zach Snyder, even used the actual comic as a storyboard for the project, but the end of the story was changed. It wouldn't be that bad if the tone of the book wasn't changed altogether. In the book all these heroes are very normal humans who just happened to become heroes, (minus Dr. Manhattan). However in the movie, the heroes are all portrayed with some superhuman level of crime fighting. The action is emphasized more than the psyche of the heroes, which is a very sad thing to see take precedence.
But to those who hadn't read the book, the movie might not have been that bad. But it still didn't do that well. The reason could be as simple as saying that it's just too obscure of a story, and that the fan base is far and few between in the general public who are generally more interested in the more recognizable superheroes like Superman and Batman, even though the Watchmen movie opened bigger than Superman: Returns or Batman Begins.
Credit: www.Fanpop.com |
But even to the general public, most will agree that the trailer for this movie was astounding, enough to catch the average person's attention, (Go watch it, it's seriously one of the best trailers I've seen). But to most, the movie was just underwhelming compared to the hype of the trailer and the expectations of the fans who knew the story. Perhaps it wasn't meant to be made into a movie, or maybe it just didn't go the direction that director Zac Snyder had hoped.
Even though Watchmen seems like it could have been made into an excellent movie, a movie cannot contain everything that made the graphic novel good. It had all the little backstories, the offshoots of parallel stories coinciding with the main tale. The truth is, unless you had a lot of time and patience, it just wouldn't make a good movie to include all of that. As an attempt, I think Watchmen might have paved a way out of obscurity but I'd like to see a newer incarnation. I bet it would work as a TV miniseries, if DC struck a deal with Amazon or something and made this into a show akin to BBC's Sherlock. Marvel has jumped into the Netflix game, maybe DC should try their hand at it and have another careful try at Watchmen again, and this time do the story the justice it deserves.Credit: www.wallpapermay.com |